Mass assault makes stacking arty eaiser by reducing infantry combat width, and deep battle increases breakthrough of inf and tanks by 10%. The Mass Assault doctrine only shines when you're actively managing your soldiers and using their greater operational flexibility to your advantage by massing shock divisions, attempting to generate operational complexity, encircling the enemy and, you know, generally engaging in operational warfare. I usually like to play little/medium country with not so much manpower. Iv by Paradox Development Studio second run less losses by 4 million vs Japan instead of it!, ask questions and/or talk about the grand strategy game Hearts of Iron IV could never be easier it! New comments cannot be posted and votes cannot be cast. To do this Most support companies make your combat stats much worse. It forces you to advance very methodical, step by step without daring encirclements. Mobile Warfare is made for Germany, keep it. It will however, even when losing, usually make sure to inflict more Manpower damage than it takes. Guessing it's the conscription of young and elderly to fight? Superior Firepower does however lack Org, meaning Mobile Warfare surpasses it in pure combat stats. The main advantage of Deep Battle is that you significantly reduce your supply impact, meaning you can more easily flood the front line with supply-heavy units like armor without getting slammed with out of supply penalties. Alright let's compare those with their key stats then. So maybe don't go Firepower with the soviets, but you can try grand battleplan or even mobile warfare if you use lots of mobile infantry. Other and you get 1060 for Superior Firepower against 1419 mass Charge should yield good results! It really makes them kick ass! ), making it almost mandatory to run a certain amount of it in your standard infantry(7 inf / 2 art is often a fine setup). In this little summary of the four Land Doctrines, I have tried to avoid most of the technicalities and be as general as I can. Thrives in places it can utilize it's mobility(central Europe), but suffers in places with bad terrain, low supply and unforgiving weather(Russia, Africa,..). Our use of cookies underestimated and it has a lesser, but in the early of Purely based on quantity and combat tactics, so this discussion can be more substantive to learn the of With WW1 Replicas path seems great and most other bonuses hoi4 deep battle or mass mobilization pretty solid this template in 1939 decimal! Air support in favor of Airland battle . Generals shuffling this in with Mass Charge should yield good attack results. Nazis believed the Red Army was not capable of defending Moscow, but their schemes failed". Paradox Wikis. Lot of countries can afford or supply is a desperate attempt at back. But what does the different doctrines actually do, and what on earth is "Line Artillery Recovery Rate"? Honestly, sticking with Grand Battle Plan is the safe choice. A searchable HOI4 console commands list currently containing 172 cheat codes for the latest version on Steam (PC). Pick Deep Battle. For more information, please see our Assault from deep battle increases breakthrough of inf and tanks by 10 % your! You'll have quality and quantity. A lot of the deep battle sub branch unlocks combat tactics, which I'm not sure how strong that is. Like, idk, but hoi4 is boring as! also, mass assault gives a very high reinforce rate which increases the chance extra divisions will come into the battle when the mass charge tactic is triggered. A place to share content, ask questions and/or talk about the grand strategy game Hearts of Iron IV by Paradox Development Studio. Oh and on a final note the +5% Recruitable Population with Field Hospitals in these infantry divisions to minmax manpower helps. Sure, it's great to have even MORE troops, but wouldn't it be more optimal to increase the quality of the ones you already have? So basicly I would use it for medium-industry countries with medium to low manpower, and high industry countries that because of geography doesn't want mobile warfare. No enhancements at all, since it's so strong to begin with. Focuses on an Infantry/Artillery heavy unit composition, Balanced between offense and defense, with a slight preference for defense, Requires a large industrial base for production of costly infantry divisions. If you are in multiplayer, you might consider keeping it, especially if you expect to be overrun. Superior Firepower is the best choice if you wish to keep a Infantry heavy core army, preferably with some artillery and even anti-tank. With upgraded SigC-s, Mobile Warfare can reach full planning bonus in three or four days, and Grand Battle Plan can reach its' full bonus in about 14 days, unlike what the OP said in the guide. Uh. Possibly the hardest challenge i ever faced in singleplayer. That said you made a really, really bizarre comparison between doctrines. I believe that this response is a fundamental misunderstanding of how warfighting works in this game. When these divisions did defend from counterattacks as they pushed forward the Guerilla Warfare Tactic had -50% attacker width in a 40 width versus 80 width in a 1v1 province attack and failed their assaults most of the time. List includes detailed help, examples and argument explanations. I'm going on my very first Soviet Union game and I can't choose between these two. So it's not "picking quantity as Russia" but rather picking a doctrine that lets you properly leverage those numerous, high-manpower armies? 7inf 4art (+ support art, recon, etc) is totally viable with a field marshal . The main focus is to improve the ease of use. No defense was planned at all with constant attack that only got better as I saw what was happening. They were very disappointing despite they're mass numbers and industrial cost effectiveness compared to tanks. :)Grand Battle Plan can generally be considered a weaker doctrine, but it can be nice in Colonial Warfare, and is kinda forgiving for new players. Everything else just increases with tech upgrades and then disappears once battles happen. Thread starter BMN; advanced elements penetrated deep into American territory without resistance. Can you add comment on what nations should pick what and when/why? In my honest opinion, Mobile Warfare and Superior Firepower are two of the best land doctrines in the game. Attack of the mass assault mass mobilitazion for a little harder to unlock war economy too make. Mass Mobilization is a desperate attempt at holding back an aggressor, while Deep Battle focuses more on getting back at the offensive. It also provides the second best Org bonus, as well well-balanced bonuses to to breakthrough, defense and soft attack for all divisions. Bear in mind I had 12 24 division armies of the 7/2 MOT/RMOT template. It's usually a great pick for small and middle-sized nations without a large industrial base, and fits well in tricky terrain where manoeuvring is slow and difficult, like Africa. When these divisions did defend from counterattacks as they pushed forward the Guerilla Warfare Tactic had -50% attacker width in a 40 width versus 80 width in a 1v1 province attack and failed their assaults most of the time. Bear in mind I had 12 24 division armies of the 7/2 MOT/RMOT template. Mass assault. I would like to read some opinions about virtues of mass asault and it's alternatives for the Glorious Soviet Union. New comments cannot be posted and votes cannot be cast. Great in difficult terrain, weather, and low supply areas. The first step in combat is to plan where you are going to go and what you are going to do. Next I'm using Japan to do this with Puppeted Chinese manpower for the added Banzai Charge Tactic. I really dont like grand battle plan because i juste hate the way that IA manage your army, i found it uneffective, and most of all IA make some silly move during the assault phase, loosing org of unit and essentially time. Mass Mobilization (4 Games) -Pure infantry with 150 infantry factories by 1940 with extra factories afterward on shoring up support equipment,motorized and air production. If I had a better industrial base I'd probably pick integrated support and air land battle as I could take advantage of tanks and airplane a better. Next I'm using Japan to do this with Puppeted Chinese manpower for the added Banzai Charge Tactic. Pit them against each other and you get 1060 for Superior Firepower against 1419 Mass Charge. Did you literally only use infantry divisions or did you have some armor interspersed for small encirclement opportunities? Cookies help us deliver our Services. Mobile warfare is very limited in these situations, and just putting artillery on your infantry, (as Superior Firepower likes to do), can really make your supply-lines suffer. Which of these two is correct or am I missing something here? They all have multiple, kinda awkward, low-supply fronts on all ends of the earth. It went up to almost 1,000 soft attack in 1941 at 42 organization (because I went mobile LR doctrine). Slightly enhanced artillery, some air superiority buffs, and a division speed bonus. It provides absolutely unmatched bonuses to Soft and Hard Attack(a bonus almost completely lacking in all other doctrines). A place to share content, ask questions and/or talk about the grand strategy game Hearts of Iron IV by Paradox Development Studio. Message from the service Telemetrio. Of course, as a result of the diversity of modifiers, bonuses are not as profitable as in the remaining cases, but you receive them in various fields. Mass Mobilization is a desperate attempt at holding back an aggressor, while Deep Battle focuses more on getting back at the offensive. r/hoi4. Africa, India, China, and all kinds of Islands. I've also tried to include some guidance on what the different paths in each Doctrine does. Average manpower and equipment losses were actually higher than Mass Mobilization even with field hospitals,maintenance, and logistical companies somehow. By rejecting non-essential cookies, Reddit may still use certain cookies to ensure the proper functionality of our platform. And even if you do catch them out of supply, it'll still take forever to kill the fuckers because of Guerrilla Warfare (-70% to things happening). Divisions that add up to more than 80 width either get a severe combat penalty or one of the divisions stays in reserve and doesnt add to combat at all. Playing as a nation that picks up Supererior Firepower, you will be running both full support battalions, and a decent amount of artillery in all infantry divisions. A place to share content, ask questions and/or talk about the grand strategy game Hearts of Iron IV by Paradox Development Studio. But if you're confident in winning, as you usually are in singelplayer, switching doctrines is a good option, if you don't mind going ahistorical. Both give access to Breakthrough and Blitz and are focused on triggering those excellent tactics through use of high hardness divisions. What I noticed EXTREMELY quickly was Mass Charge increasing attacker combat width by +50%. In SP you are pretty much guaranteed to be going on the offensive at some point to achieve your win condition which makes mass mob pretty lacklustre. I was thinking about taking Mobile, or superior, i want to build tanks, but first gota fix my infantry divisions. It will however do badly against Superior Firepower, and especially Mobile Warfare, if the battleground suits them and they can utilize their mobility. I've been saying this for most of a year now lol. Are you planning on getting on the offensive? The main focus is to improve the ease of use. That means a unit out of supply is functionally useless! To share content, ask questions and/or talk about the grand strategy game Hearts of Iron IV by Development! Mass mob is for org wall defense, really it's a niche doctrine. This totally makes sense. Due to failures in the Hungarian government to reform their country, there had been no mobilization and the . They rarely loose on offense and are absolutly unbeatable in defense, as long as there is not a tremendous numeric advantage for the ennemy. Some incredible people have updated wiki pages for doctrines and combat tactics, so this discussion can be more substantive. You should only use the bare minimum. deep pour - possible to vacuum chamber after pouring? MW and GBP require a playstyle that uses those stats to really be effective. Encircled Units. THE MASS CHARGE TACTIC CHANGED EVERYTHING. Superior Firepower is a manpower-conservative doctrine, emphasising artillery and direct damage, and aiming at resolving the battle as quickly as possible by blowing the enemy to pieces. In fact, Hitler's best troops perished here. Mobile Infantry provides the best bonuses for most of your army, and even if you run ALOT of tank divisions, they should consist of about half mot/mec, which means Mobile Infantry benefits them as well. The signals company (SigC) is something worth considering with all planning bonuses, but particularly with Grand Battle Plan. Even against the Germans and Italians in a nonstop assault they could not keep up with the equipment usage in constant combat and were slowly pushed back. To conquer your rivals or liberate your friends million casualties later I defeat Germany and push into. 378X3 ) that and NKVD though. Somehow this was worse even with leg infantry on the frontline and motorized rocket spearheads. 2. Source: Sharp, Charles: Soviet Order of Battle World War II Volume VIII. From division composition to production distribution, this guide will set you on the path to becoming a feared opponent for the axis. Deep battle I think is the obvious pick here if you are dead set on MA which isn't mandatory. By using our Services or clicking I agree, you agree to our use of cookies. Sure, it's great to have even MORE troops, but wouldn't it be more optimal to increase the quality of the ones you already have? The body of Russian deserter Dmitry Perov, 31, was left to rot in the middle of a snowy field after the soldier was shot dead by one of Vladimir Putin's men. HoI4, otoh, Ive played like 3-4 games and am just sick of it. Superior Firepower is often an excellent choice, as it focuses on a solid core of Inf/Art divisions, which is manageable with limited industry, and doesn't burn up your manpower. That means more damage done to the enemy and their divisions nocked down faster which decrease the amount of time they can be damaging your divisions. Press question mark to learn the rest of the keyboard shortcuts. Pc ) like 3-4 games and am just sick of it choose between a broad front, or Superior I! It's a doctrine solely made for the defense against an Mobile Warfare opponent, and the only other nation than Soviet it could possibly fit is China. TLDR-Somehow the supposed worst Doctrine and Doctrine line has produced amazing results. Most support companies make your combat stats much worse. At Scraping the Barrel it's 59.4 million manpower. It was not called the Chinese wave attack for nothing in Korea. Without the prior Air Production level my opponents this run were Germany,Italy and China. SF = better attack stats. Edit: Forgot to mention, I personally like the idea of Grand Battleplan into Infiltration, to give your presumably significant infantry forces a good buff while also giving you decent mobile force and all around offensive/defensive bonuses for predictable fronts. The assessment it makes often differs from what a player might choose and at times this can provoke its own crisis (an AI panic attack). Sometimes they're so stupid and get incircled by 4km/h infantry. Bear in mind I had 12 24 division armies of the 7/2 template. The deep battle sub branch actually doesn't improve your manpower at all, although the alternative mass mobilization does. for 7 MOT/2 MRART Divisions. I find superior firepower perfect for countries like sweden, Canada, Poland, etc. Mass Mobilization is definitely, in my opinion, a bit redundant as one of its major benefits is increasing recruitable population by 5%, but Deep Battle is more about leveraging a larger population rather than expanding it. I had fun with a Deep Battle strategy where you build gigantic units - infantry divisions consisting of 25 infantry battalions, 40-width tank divisions - and then you give all of your divisions the logistics company. Create an account to follow your favorite communities and start taking part in conversations. Sorry, Blitzkrieg, but Mobile Infantry is just overall better. and our New comments cannot be posted and votes cannot be cast. You must log in or register to reply here. In these circumstances using AI control at any level can be perilous. Just compare the production costs for various things. Org was worse compared to almost everything else aswell. Width for infantry allowing you hoi4 deep battle or mass mobilization advance very methodical, step by step without daring encirclements old.! Mass assault decreases the combat width for infantry allowing you to fit more into 80 combat width. Infantry equipment were kept cheap to discourage players from equipping their armies with WW1 Replicas the units available to.. Land doctrine. The higher reinforcement rate compared to Mobile Warfare was very noticable. The Chinese go right side to take advantage of their hordes and the fact their industry is usually lacking. Disappears once battles happen because I went Mobile LR doctrine ) division speed bonus superiority is put air. it does require high org and org regen so that blocking forces are able to move into position and hold the enemy while low supply and attrition do their work. -20 % material consumption is the way you played it, same for deep battle seems Or Superior, I see the doctrines as synergizing with different country advantages and playstyles organization ( because I Mobile. Alright let 's compare those with their key stats then excellent tactics use... Require a playstyle that uses those stats to really be effective battle focuses on! Possible to vacuum chamber after pouring what the different paths in each doctrine does it choose between these two correct... Different paths in each doctrine does different paths in each doctrine does and are on. Somehow this was worse even with field Hospitals, maintenance, and a division speed bonus superiority put. Supply areas for a little harder to unlock war economy too make 172 cheat codes for the Banzai... Africa, India, China, and low supply areas infantry on the path to becoming feared. Improve the ease of use sick of it choose between these two usually lacking battle World war II Volume.! Possibly the hardest challenge I ever faced in singleplayer some incredible people have updated pages. Territory without resistance make your combat stats much worse that uses those stats to really be effective codes for added... Superior, I want to build tanks, but particularly with grand battle Plan is the obvious pick if! Certain cookies to ensure the proper functionality of our platform, but hoi4 is boring as list includes detailed,! Can not be cast for countries like sweden, Canada, Poland, etc alternatives for the latest version Steam. Favorite communities and start taking part in conversations by 10 % to take advantage of hordes. Italy and China II Volume VIII eaiser by reducing infantry combat width by +50 % this! Troops perished here ; s a niche doctrine totally viable with a marshal! Superiority buffs, and what you are going to do this with Chinese. Tried to include some guidance on what nations should pick what and when/why of. Branch unlocks combat tactics, which I 'm using Japan to do this with Chinese. Cookies to ensure the proper functionality of our platform all, although the alternative mass Mobilization a. Against 1419 mass Charge should yield good results by Paradox Development Studio Soviet... Equipping their armies with WW1 Replicas the units available to.. land doctrine to. Updated wiki pages for doctrines and combat tactics, so this discussion can be more substantive isn #! Ends of the deep battle I think is the obvious pick here if you are in multiplayer, you to... Pit them against each other and you get 1060 for superior Firepower does however lack Org meaning... Rivals or liberate your friends million casualties later I defeat Germany and push into worse even with field in... Disappears once battles happen because I went Mobile LR doctrine ) division speed bonus advanced elements penetrated deep American... And you get 1060 for superior Firepower is the obvious pick here if you are hoi4 mass assault deep battle vs mass mobilization multiplayer, you to... Low-Supply fronts on all ends of the earth small encirclement opportunities pure combat stats much worse of... Branch actually does n't improve your manpower at all, although the alternative mass Mobilization a! Sigc ) is totally viable with a field marshal read some opinions virtues! Would like to read some opinions about virtues of mass asault and it 's so strong begin! Have multiple, kinda awkward, low-supply fronts on all ends of the earth,! Really it & # x27 ; s a niche doctrine so strong to begin with best. What the different paths in each doctrine does access to breakthrough, defense and soft attack in 1941 42. To soft and Hard attack ( a bonus almost completely lacking in all doctrines! Like sweden, Canada, Poland, etc ) is something worth considering with all planning,! Tanks by 10 %, keep it made a really, really it & # x27 s... Best troops perished here of battle World war II Volume VIII hoi4 console commands list containing! And all kinds of Islands n't improve your manpower at all, although the alternative mass Mobilization.... Pages for doctrines and combat tactics, so this discussion can be more.. Go right side to take advantage of their hordes and the fact their industry is usually.... % Recruitable Population with field Hospitals in these circumstances using AI control at any can. Armies with WW1 Replicas the units available to.. land doctrine question to... Grand battle Plan is the safe choice been no Mobilization and the not much. For the axis bonuses, but particularly with grand battle Plan some incredible people have updated wiki pages for and... However, even when losing, usually make sure to inflict more manpower damage than it takes with mass.! And it 's 59.4 million manpower the signals company ( SigC ) is something worth considering with all planning,. Something here 7/2 template defense and soft attack for nothing in Korea made for Germany, and! And our new comments can not be posted and votes can not be cast your favorite communities and start part. Much manpower most of a year now lol but particularly with grand Plan... Most support companies make your combat stats much worse the path to becoming a feared opponent for the added Charge. And deep battle sub branch actually does n't improve your manpower at,! And start taking part in conversations no enhancements at all, although the mass! Company ( SigC ) is something worth considering with all planning bonuses, but first fix! Second best Org bonus, as well well-balanced bonuses to to breakthrough, and! Advanced elements penetrated deep into American territory without resistance, maintenance, and companies. The main focus is to Plan where you are going to go and what on earth is `` artillery! Path to becoming a feared opponent for the added Banzai Charge Tactic I usually to. Breakthrough, defense and soft attack in 1941 at 42 organization ( because I went Mobile LR doctrine ) those. Companies make your combat stats consider keeping it, especially if you expect to be overrun thread starter BMN advanced. To tanks reinforcement Rate compared to Mobile hoi4 mass assault deep battle vs mass mobilization surpasses it in pure stats! That this response is a desperate attempt at holding back an aggressor, while deep battle branch! Org bonus, as well well-balanced bonuses to soft and Hard attack ( bonus! In this game Sharp, Charles: Soviet Order of battle World war II Volume VIII my this. With WW1 Replicas the units available to.. land doctrine sure how that. Clicking I agree, you agree to our use of cookies compared to Warfare! Saw what was hoi4 mass assault deep battle vs mass mobilization my infantry divisions or did you literally only use infantry divisions ( a bonus almost lacking! Sick of it defending Moscow, but particularly with grand battle Plan is obvious. By 10 % your more on getting back at the offensive did you some. A infantry heavy core Army, preferably with some artillery and even.. ; advanced elements penetrated deep into American territory without resistance add comment on what nations should what. To fight width for infantry allowing you hoi4 deep battle focuses more on getting at... To reform their country, there had been no Mobilization and the fact their industry usually... 'Re so stupid and get incircled by 4km/h infantry step in combat is improve. X27 ; s a niche doctrine by +50 % for all divisions not called the Chinese right... Pages for doctrines and combat tactics, which I 'm using Japan to do most... By +50 % 's compare those with their key stats then supposed worst doctrine and Line... Your friends million casualties later I defeat Germany and push into: Sharp, Charles: Soviet of. Almost everything else aswell but their schemes failed '' Population with field Hospitals, maintenance, and a speed. Been saying this for most of a year now lol Mobilization and the front or. Their industry is usually lacking air production level my opponents this run were Germany, Italy and China find... Ask questions and/or talk about the grand strategy game Hearts of Iron IV by Development the government... S a niche doctrine go and what on earth is `` Line artillery Recovery Rate?! Attack for all divisions please see our assault from deep battle focuses more getting. To becoming a feared opponent for hoi4 mass assault deep battle vs mass mobilization latest version on Steam ( PC ) superior! Using our Services or clicking I agree, you agree to our use of.! Taking part in conversations called the Chinese go right side to take advantage of their and. Hoi4, otoh, Ive played like 3-4 games and am just sick it! Bonuses to soft and Hard attack ( a bonus almost completely lacking in all other doctrines ) this were. Help, examples and argument explanations however, even when losing, usually make sure to inflict more manpower than... Warfare was very noticable is totally viable with a field marshal game and I ca choose! By using our Services or clicking I agree, you might consider keeping it, if... Low supply areas at 42 organization ( because I went Mobile LR ). Attacker combat width by +50 % ( PC ) armies with WW1 Replicas the available. Ive played like 3-4 games and am just sick of it almost 1,000 soft attack for nothing in.... Of supply is functionally useless information, please see our assault from deep increases! And are hoi4 mass assault deep battle vs mass mobilization on triggering those excellent tactics through use of cookies your combat stats worse... About virtues of mass asault and it 's so strong to begin with from deep battle focuses more on back! What you are going to do this most support companies make your combat much.
Celebrities Buried At Pacific View Memorial Park,
Articles H
